Paralimbic cortex had longer SEEG knee time scales but shorter BOLD time scales than heteromodal cortex in two human cohorts
We tested whether a cortical time scale order transfers between human SEEG and fMRI from separate studies. We used public RAM electrical fits and MICA-MICs BOLD time series. BOLD contrasts used the same named-region sets as the SEEG coverage. Paralimbic minus heteromodal log10 time scale was +0.2107 in 61 SEEG patients (95% person bootstrap range +0.1332 to +0.2925) and -0.3654 in 48 complete BOLD participants (-0.3893 to -0.3422). Both Holm p values were 0.00008 across four planned tests. Resampling both cohorts kept the BOLD range negative. Alternative BOLD estimators, edge removal, and single-region removal retained the opposite mean signs. The heteromodal-to-primary/unimodal contrast was positive in BOLD but uncertain in SEEG. Electrical adjustment for fitted exponent reduced the paralimbic contrast to +0.0643, with a range that included zero. These results show a failure of the tested order to transfer. They do not identify the cause. Epilepsy and memory-task SEEG differ from healthy resting BOLD in cohort, state, frequency, spatial scale, and measurement. The package preserves code, inputs, source hashes, all results, uncertainty draws, figures, and repeat steps. Independent calculations matched 757 selected source fits and the new autocorrelations.
human neuroscience · SEEG · fMRI · time scales · cross-modal comparison · measurement · cortical hierarchy · reproducibility
References
8- usesSEEG knee timescales follow a limbic-to-neocortical axis, not a neocortical hierarchy sci:sha256:23553ec6d4bacb9bd5d4044553a75899ac170080f3e19ec2e574953b5c527d1e
We reuse archived fit and electrode tables and the fixed Desikan class lists.
- usesMedial temporal SEEG pairs had longer aperiodic-knee timescales than lateral pairs in 206 RAM patients sci:sha256:5baa137385890b67e049fc04ffb0e904ebd31927f9bb21f7810e5e1f94328bf1
We reuse knee fits and independently check its fitting method on selected source spectra.
- usesIn 261 RAM SEEG subjects aged 18–64, 4–13 Hz peak frequency did not decrease with age, while peak height and relative alpha power increased sci:sha256:0e36e73fa7707bba416e7d46869f09378b140e05e39d6e785874fd9baeda4c32
We reuse selected source spectra, source hashes, and raw-block provenance.
- doi:10.7554/eLife.61277
- doi:10.1162/IMAG.a.1248
- doi:10.1038/s41597-022-01682-y
- doi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004789.v3.1.0
- doi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004809.v2.2.0
Cited by
2 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- usesNone of six selected cortical time scale orders passed both SEEG and fMRI sign tests in test participants
We reuse its verified source fits, contact labels, BOLD time series, source receipts and regional processing code. We add split participant regional prediction tests.
- Cortical band median frequency rose with height in FR1 SEEG and fell in HCP resting fMRI after position controls
Related transfer test found in the catalog after our plans. It did not set this analysis, and overlapping data are not independent confirmation.