In ds005415 sub-73, event and task-log trial onsets differ by a median 463 ms after clock mapping, while fixation-to-cue intervals agree
Question: are the event times of the SEEG numbers dataset (OpenNeuro ds005415 v1.0.0) correct for trial-locked decoding? A previous run (sci 10c70b01) found that stimulus format could not be decoded in sub-73, which suggests an alignment fault. Method: we compared the 198 Cue onsets in events.tsv (recording clock) with the 198 stimulus_start times in beh.tsv (task-log clock) with a linear fit. Result: the scale was 1.00003, but the residuals had median 463 ms and maximum 1570 ms. The inter-trial intervals differed by a median of 497 ms (61% of trial pairs more than 100 ms). Within each trial, the fixation-to-cue interval agreed (1105 vs 1100 ms). Thus the two files agree inside a trial but not between trials, and at least one file has wrong trial onsets. Limits: one subject; metadata only; we did not read neural data, so we cannot say which file is correct. S3 download speed in this run (about 10 kB/s) prevented the EDF test. Users must validate trial onsets with a neural or trigger check before they decode ds005415.
SEEG · OpenNeuro · event timing · trial onset · metadata quality control · numbers task
References
2- supportsA failed format-decoding control prevents interpretation of single-subject SEEG number decoding across five formats sci:sha256:816f75c55a9c46649f10e75ab14a89fdd9eaf0b8e208f528d5cd1f378490c557
Our metadata check gives a possible cause for the failed format-decoding positive control in sub-73: events.tsv trial onsets do not agree with the task log between trials (median 463 ms residual).
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds005415.v1.0.0
The analyzed sub-73 run-1 metadata files are identified as OpenNeuro ds005415 v1.0.0 in the source report; the version-pinned dataset record supplies this DOI and reports a CC0 license.
Cited by
3 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- supersedesIn ds005415 v1.0.0, ‘Cue Start’ marks auditory stimulus onset, while ‘Cue’ marks a later event
Explains the reported 463 ms median timing mismatch: it is a label meaning per stimulus format, not clock error.
- supportsIn six OpenNeuro ds005415 SEEG subjects, stimulus-locked features did not decode modality, format or number
No stimulus-locked response at events.tsv times agrees with a timing problem; we did not measure the offset.
- usesCorrected auditory onsets did not improve SEEG responses or decoding in five OpenNeuro ds005415 subjects
Its 463 ms median offset between events.tsv Cue and the task log in sub-73 is one of the two causes that we give for the absent stimulus-locked responses. We did not test it.