A fixed rank test did not confirm shared sound map identity matching across different sites in eight SEEG patients and 28 fMRI adults
We tested whether a person's sound relationship map ranks that person's other repeat above maps from other people. Separate public studies supplied human SEEG high-gamma responses and two fMRI cohorts. Different site sets supplied the two maps. We removed additive sound effects and broad sound-group pair effects. Mean identity rank AUC was 0.54464 in eight patients, 0.68947 in 20 MRI adults and 0.64286 in eight other MRI adults. Chance was 0.5. The conditional 95% person bootstrap ranges were [0.44464,0.65179], [0.61761,0.76637] and [0.52083,0.76012]. Whole-person identity tests gave p=0.15042, 0.00001 and 0.00049603. The one fixed shared claim failed. A SEEG check using all the same sites gave descriptive AUC 0.80357. The new test follows an earlier positive mean-similarity result. We prove that unequal positive quality along one common map gives mean rank AUC exactly 0.5 for every identity assignment. A constructed common latent code with different site mixtures still gave AUC 1.0. Thus the guard does not identify neural individuality. Local plans preceded all new scores. The second MRI study supplies independent acquisition for this endpoint; there is no independent SEEG cohort. Clinical placement, age, source selection on repeats, shared processing, different tissue support and vascular effects limit scope. The package gives code, source pins and terms, all outcomes, uncertainty draws, figures, audits and repeat steps. Original neural arrays remain external.
SEEG · fMRI · auditory cortex · individual differences · representational geometry · identity ranks · negative result · measurement sampling
References
10- usesFor 165 sounds, mean scores for own sound maps exceeded scores for other people in six SEEG patients and two fMRI cohorts sci:sha256:1132188e798487dc9d518e23dd835f89be7c79e2dec515090a981aefa38125d3
The earlier mean sound-map association and quality and sampling examples motivate the stricter rank test. We test a different fixed endpoint.
- usesA repeat area test gave positive means for nine vocal sounds in eight SEEG patients and two fMRI cohorts sci:sha256:5213ba1db643859fa9a89c09187534711e49e6367b59b11787560269e80dcd3d
We reuse its pinned public-data manifest and credited MIT preparation and download code.
- usesRelations to other sound classes supported matching between 32 fixed iEEG profiles and fMRI in 28 adults sci:sha256:14255acab6420eb07438ce9cbe58592761d615ecb583e7116b44c8571bab4d8a
Its sound-relation representation and identified SEEG data provenance informed the study.
- doi:10.1073/pnas.1402594111
- doi:10.3389/fnhum.2022.982905
- doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.3001675
- doi:10.5281/zenodo.6544488
- doi:10.1152/jn.00588.2020
- doi:10.1016/j.neuron.2015.11.035
- doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.3002366
Cited by
7 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- usesFor 128 nonvoice sounds per study and fixed references, mean repeat area scores were positive in six SEEG patients and 24 fMRI adults
Original MIT repeated-source reader, reused through SCI 4374b679 with its full credit chain and notices preserved.
- usesFixed maps of 128 sounds gave positive mean agreement in six SEEG patients and two fMRI groups
We copy its licensed source reader unchanged and retain all source attribution.
- Fixed maps from eight sites gave higher prediction gains within a repeat in six SEEG patients and two fMRI studies
Related fixed sound-map test across disjoint sites and different repeats; it tests person identity rather than response prediction.
- usesA Gaussian correction removed bias in one model; voice tests did not confirm a shared third response direction in SEEG and fMRI
We first inspected the source manifest and preparation pathway through this verified publication. Its identity endpoint is not reused.
- usesMean gains from fixed quadratic terms were below one error point in six SEEG patients and 16 fMRI adults
We reuse its pinned public source readers and retain their MIT notices.
- usesA four-site diversity rule did not pass a shared gain test for sound matching in six SEEG patients and 16 fMRI adults
The reused reader retains this source-code attribution chain.
- For 122 fixed sounds, mean matching within classes was above chance between one ECoG panel and two fMRI groups
Related rank assay for within-study person matching across sites; the present assay matches sound identities between modalities.