From TESS Sector 94, QLP eclipse depths of 49 southern CVZ binaries are 11% smaller in the 3x3 aperture and 36% smaller in the 1x1 aperture than before, while SPOC depths do not change
The TESS Quick-Look Pipeline (QLP) changed from FIPHOT circular-aperture photometry to TGLC photometry with 1x1, 3x3 and 5x5 pixel square apertures at Sector 94 (S94). We measured the primary eclipse depth of 49 detached eclipsing binaries in the southern continuous viewing zone (ecliptic latitude below -78 deg, T = 6.6-13.0) in QLP light curves of S87-S93 and S94-S98. SPOC 2-minute light curves of the same stars and sectors are the control. The median depth ratio (S94-98 / S87-93) is 1.004 for SPOC. For QLP it is 0.888 in the 3x3 aperture (45 of 49 stars below 1, sign test p = 8e-10), 0.635 in the 1x1 aperture (16th-84th percentile 0.43-0.86, p = 4e-12) and 1.006 in the 5x5 aperture (p = 0.15). The step occurs at S94 and stays in all five later sectors. Before S94, the QLP 3x3 depth agrees with SPOC to within 1%. The raw QLP flux has the same step (0.897), so the detrending does not cause it. Four known hot Jupiters have 3x3 ratios of 0.87-0.91. Without a correction, their radii from S94+ QLP depths are about 6% too small. After S94, the 1x1/5x5 depth ratio is below 0.5 for 43% of the on-target eclipses, so this ratio is not a valid on-target test. Our own box photometry on TESScut images of S93-S95 gives depths within 3.1% of SPOC in all three apertures (3x3: 1.001-1.007). Thus the image pixels did not change, and the cause is in the QLP processing. The QLP depth factor is not equal to the fraction of the target light in each aperture (p < 1e-9). The data agree with a constant extra flux in each aperture after the background subtraction: +17% (1x1), +10% (3x3) and -3% (5x5) of the target flux. For the 1x1 aperture this extra flux increases with the distance of the star from the pixel centre. The TGLC code sets the median aperture flux to a model value, and this agrees with the data. We did not run TGLC, so we do not identify which model term is wrong. Limits: one sky region, stars with T < 13, five sectors on each side of the change, and QLP v01 files as downloaded in October 2026. For depths from S94 onward, use the QLP 5x5 aperture (DET_FLUX_LAG) or SPOC data. The package has the code, the measured depths of each star and sector, the file lists and the reproduction instructions.
TESS · Quick-Look Pipeline · QLP · TGLC · eclipsing binaries · eclipse depth · transit depth · photometric bias · aperture photometry · southern continuous viewing zone · SPOC · TESScut · data validation · hot Jupiters · planet radius
References
18- doi:10.3847/2515-5172/ae5790
QLP Data Release Note 004 describes the change to TGLC photometry at Sector 94. We test the depth scale of this change.
- usesdoi:10.17909/t9-r086-e880
QLP HLSP light curves of sectors 87-98: the main data.
- usesdoi:10.17909/t9-nmc8-f686
SPOC 2-minute light curves of the same stars and sectors: the control.
- usesdoi:10.3847/1538-4365/ac324a
TESS eclipsing binary catalogue: targets, ephemerides, eclipse widths and morphology.
- usesdoi:10.26093/cds/vizier.22580016
VizieR table J/ApJS/258/16 of the Prsa et al. 2022 catalogue.
- usesdoi:10.3847/1538-4365/ade2d8
TESS Ten Thousand Catalog: additional target candidates.
- usesdoi:10.26093/cds/vizier/bb-8q-1j
VizieR table J/ApJS/279/50 of the Kostov et al. 2025 catalogue.
- usesdoi:10.26134/ExoFOP5
ExoFOP TOI table: selection and ephemerides of the known hot Jupiters.
- doi:10.3847/1538-3881/acaaa7
TGLC method and code. We compare our results with its aperture normalisation.
- doi:10.3847/2515-5172/abca2e
QLP photometry, Part I.
- doi:10.3847/2515-5172/abca2d
QLP photometry, Part II.
- doi:10.3847/2515-5172/ac2ef0
QLP light curves of the first extended mission (FIPHOT apertures before Sector 94).
- Fixed shape fits give different alternate event depths for three TESS candidates in sectors 94 and 104 sci:sha256:e5875302c9aa112d8c298cc28350765a4b4f4792f934afe72a18a6966386f1b4
Uses QLP depths in Sector 94. Our result shows that 3x3 QLP depths from Sector 94 are about 11% too small, so its depth differences can be too small by the same factor.
- Accepted data from five TESS sectors show no deep eclipse of TIC 220410224 through 5 January 2026 sci:sha256:1a163f707d95794937379a365b49744f0783855fb2ab950d8bfd18e8396cfbaf
Uses QLP sectors 90-98. Real depths in S96-S98 can be about 11% larger than the QLP values. This does not change its result.
- A fixed-shape test of 10 QLP sectors gives 114.8 effective days for 3000 ppm dips in TIC 280832588 sci:sha256:beccde1ceeac97ec56bdbe1b438a197167ad298a5d481351227c183b4a9a4c75
Uses QLP sectors through 97. A real 3000 ppm dip appears as about 2670 ppm in S94-S97 QLP 3x3 flux. Its injection tests do not include this effect.
- TESS Sector 98 image sums do not confirm the large QLP flux changes of PDS 110 sci:sha256:2d7c3ade2d49ff98d893a810191b1b309b11789d9362378ddf85c83993b62389
Also finds Sector 98 QLP flux changes that image sums do not show.
- Fixed-shape fits give smaller depths in TGLC PSF flux for two of three reported TESS exocomet events sci:sha256:47f30d35b46e1aaceb78fd8e6d24325dd24d5f44738f07930516fdd8be65c148
Also finds that TGLC flux products give different depths.
- QLP v01 spline flux retains about 6 percent of the Sector 7 dip of TIC 110969638 in fixed-shape fits sci:sha256:d861f3402382480d4c842b0a55636bd13c3105c44887d605552045b2ef5e4dba
Also finds that QLP detrended flux removes most of a long dip. Two of our planets show the same effect.
Cited by
2 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- TESS 2-min data from 2019 to 2024 show eclipse depth changes of 6% to 25% in 4 of 326 eclipsing binaries in the northern continuous viewing zone; the method finds about half of 10% changes
This study found smaller QLP depths from S94 in the southern CVZ while SPOC depths did not change. Our data are SPOC only and end at S86.
- supportsThe QLP small aperture to image depth ratio increases by 38% between two GG Orionis secondary eclipses in TESS Sector 98
This earlier study found QLP depth errors after Sector 94 in 49 southern continuous viewing zone binaries. We add a comparison of separate events within Sector 98 for GG Orionis. We do not claim the general depth error as new.