Missing covariance leaves 29 of 821 selected linear transit clocks undecided at three errors and a 30-minute limit in 2030
We test whether published marginal errors can decide a future transit timing limit when period and reference time covariance is unknown. The NASA Exoplanet Archive query from 21 October 2026 has 36,477 rows for 4,815 transiting planets. We retain 1,790 complete source rows for 821 planets. Each row has an explicit BJD-TDB time label, symmetric signed errors, and no limit flag. Planets with any archive timing variation or controversy flag are excluded. We assume a constant period and treat the quoted errors as standard deviations. The exact bounds at cycle n are the absolute difference and the sum of the epoch error and |n| times the period error. At the model transit nearest BJD-TDB 2462502.5, 565 planets have a row for which three times the error is at most 30 minutes for every allowed correlation. Every eligible row fails for every allowed correlation for 227 planets. The other 29 planets depend on the unknown correlation. A zero-correlation assumption gives 579 passes; 14 are in the undecided group. Thus, the missing correlation cannot change 792 of the 821 decisions under these rules. The undecided counts are 32 in 2027 and 18 in 2035 at the same limit. Independent decimal arithmetic reproduced all 5,370 primary forecasts and all annual classes. We preserve source rows, references, rejection ledgers, code, figures, and sensitivity checks. The contribution is a conditional precision audit and a decision dataset. It does not validate future timing coverage, find a new planet, or establish a physical timing change. Other source rows and newer literature can alter these results from the archive.
exoplanets · transit ephemerides · uncertainty propagation · covariance · NASA Exoplanet Archive · observation planning · reproducible research
References
7- usesdoi:10.26133/NEA12
The frozen Planetary Systems query supplies all numerical source rows. The access date is 21 October 2026.
- doi:10.3847/PSJ/ade3c2
This paper describes the NASA Exoplanet Archive.
- supportsdoi:10.1051/0004-6361/201425368
This work establishes prediction error propagation and the effect of reference epoch choice under a constant period.
- supportsReference times from the period sources reduce TESS offsets below two standard errors for HAT-P-16 b and WASP-20 b sci:sha256:e0e338d8e7d5624f3ff8bbfc3e295a665bb8ece57475ead7ecc8116934c57bac
This prior audit applies the same covariance bounds to small sets of source-matched ephemerides and measured TESS times. Our new test concerns a future precision decision for 821 selected planets. We reuse no data or code from it.
- supportsLinear transit predictions with scaled errors had 98.06% mean coverage at three errors in a 70/30 test of 1229 Kepler objects sci:sha256:ccb7c433d9452451054515cecf761ee042fd0dc70d63bcb87e977a89dc05a891
Its Kepler coverage test shows why propagation of formal errors does not establish actual coverage. We keep our bound result conditional on the linear clock and quoted error model.
- doi:10.3847/1538-4365/ac9da4
This source supplies many complete ephemerides through the archive. The saved rows retain all source references.
- doi:10.3847/1538-4365/ae3238
ExoClock IV supplies newer ephemerides. It limits any claim that the frozen archive rows give the best current literature clock.
Cited by
4 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- usesAdding 0.5 day to an archive epoch removes the WASP-21 b flag in a 390-planet linear transit clock audit near 2027
Prior SCI use of a missing-covariance timing bound for selected linear clocks. We use the same bound with new all-pairs code and data.
- Formal transit search spans at three standard errors exceed eight hours for 86 of 302 selected constant-period clocks in 2027–2029
This prior covariance census provides context for decisions from marginal timing errors. Its precision census is distinct from our window test.
- Independent 60-second times would bound 764/769 selected linear 2030 transit standard errors within five minutes at every old correlation
This earlier study classified old transit errors with unknown covariance. Our contribution constructs and tests an update with one new independent time.
- Two 2024 TESS sectors show a repeated TrES-5 b offset from the selected 2022 linear clock
This earlier study tests future formal timing errors with missing covariance.