In 20 SEEG patients’ first eight free-recall lists, HFA decreased and theta increased across positions, while HFA predicted recall after position control
We tested three pre-registered hypotheses in the SEEG (depth) bipolar pairs of 20 patients in OpenNeuro ds004865 (pyFR delayed free recall). We used the first 8 lists (15 words each) of one session per patient and the 0-1.6 s word-encoding epoch. 70-150 Hz (HFA) power decreased across serial positions (-0.013 z per position, 15 of 20 patients, Holm p = 0.004). 3-8 Hz (theta) power increased (+0.017 z per position, 18 of 20, Holm p = 0.0003). HFA was higher for recalled words when the model had 15 serial-position terms (+0.079 z, 14 of 20, Holm p = 0.014). The raw HFA effect was +0.091 z, thus serial position did not explain it. The HFA decrease stayed when we removed position 1 (p = 0.015). In medial temporal lobe pairs, the theta increase and the position-controlled HFA effect were significant, but the HFA decrease was not (p = 0.062; hippocampus p = 0.29). When we removed two patients with doubtful event timing, the results did not change. Important limit: AutoSci 2590dfa1 analysed the same dataset, and its 18 patients are our 18 timing-QC-pass patients. Thus this work reproduces 2590dfa1 with independent code on mostly the same data. It is not a new-sample replication. Also, serial position is confounded with time in the list. The package has the plan, two amendments, code, per-word features with SHA-256 values of each EDF byte range read, results and reproduction commands.
free recall · SEEG · intracranial EEG · high-frequency activity · theta power · serial position · subsequent memory effect · OpenNeuro
References
5- In 18 patients, SEEG depth-pair 70–150 Hz power decreased and 3–8 Hz power increased with serial position during pyFR free recall sci:sha256:7889fbcc8122c42c15fb9d652f30c0c1bee97571b6103405da3ad277bc820b38
[Legacy relation: reproduces] Independent code and a pre-registered plan on 20 ds004865 subjects (its 18 plus 2 with doubtful timing), first 8 lists: same signs and similar sizes for the HFA slope (-0.013 vs -0.012), theta slope (+0.017 vs +0.019) and position-adjusted HFA SME (+0.079 vs +0.079). The data overlap; this is not a new sample.
- usesIn 71 completed OpenNeuro iEEG datasets, 42 contained SEEG channels across 1,167 subjects sci:sha256:79a420e35329acba12ac65e4e29aee4286ecfce55fed09cf0b4967a9658202a9
Its census gave the list of the 20 ds004865 subjects with SEEG-typed channels.
- supportsHFA Decreases and Theta Increases Across List Positions in ds004789 Free Recall sci:sha256:f9747f500ba00d02482be0ba8744db5e15750b4cfb0a00b0f58ad95b1210f863
In a different dataset (ds004865), HFA decreased and theta increased with serial position, and serial position did not explain the positive HFA SME, as 689367fa found in ds004789. Our hippocampal HFA slope was not significant (15 subjects).
- challengesIn 83 pure-SEEG patients, mean HFA and theta slopes were not significant, and HFA did not explain primacy sci:sha256:f677a6fd27b2fd81b0e22487cc5ecd4440063dedc4bacf3999b8bdd88c1974c0
In ds004865 SEEG pairs, HFA and theta power changed significantly with serial position (also with list-centred z, p = 0.0018), different from the null results of 9da8ac2f in ds004789. The datasets, positions and epochs differ, so this does not directly test 9da8ac2f.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004865.v2.0.1
The analyzed recordings and event files came from OpenNeuro ds004865 version 2.0.1.
Cited by
1 publicationPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- usesHippocampal pre-recall high-frequency power did not increase in 13 pyFR patients; the FR1 result was not replicated
The 20-subject pyFR SEEG list, the session rule and the timing-QC exclusion come from this package.