Nine states of one scalar reproduced eight-site sound means in separate human SEEG and fMRI studies
Time averaging can hide a scalar with fixed monotone readouts. We give an exact construction for any finite real mean map with free readout offsets, ranges and condition-specific dwell times. P coordinates need at most P+1 fixed scalar states. The universal finite-state bound is sharp. A range formula is exact within a one-jump threshold family. Separate public studies supplied SEEG from eight patients and fMRI from 28 adults. Fixed eight-site panels had 165 sound means per person. Nine states reproduced all maps within 9.42e-16 of each coordinate mean range. Reserved applications used six patients, 16 B2021 adults and eight NH2015 adults. Mean required range factors were 4.3515, 4.3490 and 3.9520. Independent time integrals and integer programs checked all 36 fits. An exact positive-output example had crossed mean orders, nonzero area and zero repeat variance. A stricter check froze readers from repeat 0. It failed on at least one later sound in 29 of 30 reserved people. Later weights used later outcomes, so this was not prediction. The result is a measurement limit and a checked tool. It does not establish one-dimensional brain activity, a shared neural code or causality. Condition-driven dwell times retain model complexity. Different cohorts, clinical sampling, source screens, filters, time scales and vascular effects limit biological interpretation. The package supplies code, proof, source pins and terms, all scalar results, figures and repeat instructions. Neural arrays remain external.
human neuroscience · SEEG · fMRI · time averaging · monotone readout · neural dimensionality · scalar mixture · measurement limits · reproducibility
References
15- usesThree-sound order tests failed in six SEEG patients and 24 fMRI adults under fixed repeat rules sci:sha256:c7721744b05fc5066df321fe4a759620d487e05d7f8cade8a3ab82956596571b
Its three-sound order assay and class-averaging limit motivated this time-averaging question. Its failed tests are preserved as prior work.
- A shared sound-order test failed in 20 iEEG patients and 16 fMRI adults; common-average reference can create a perfect reversal from one monotone drive sci:sha256:5fbb96215d343a1ad6585ba03d8b492e38aaa28ab1eb1a2f3b95a3f7db277a51
Prior exact reference-effect counterexample for a monotone scalar order test.
- With stable means and independent repeat errors, mean finger response area was positive in five ECoG patients and six fMRI adults after feature mean removal sci:sha256:c293e29d52d8957ad7829a7235f89165da8ef76f78c8e034b10849250c73db0d
Prior finite-repeat area benchmark and deterministic nonlinear measurement limit.
- usesFor 165 fixed sounds, category planes kept more mean within-group repeat covariance than shuffled planes in SEEG and fMRI sci:sha256:6b28d4dc432cd1fe235149928317944c823d96f02d3774383d4619376f802176
We reuse its MIT repeated-response reader, source pins and retained upstream attribution. Its category-plane endpoint is not reused.
- usesWith 165 sounds per study, matching repeats gave higher spatial forecast scores in six SEEG patients and eight fMRI adults sci:sha256:6752538e2180c9fbd42e046330de585a707f4a4d4aad7cce2f9b1b5d38346f84
Upstream reader credited by SCI 1ec7a572; its source notices are retained.
- usesCalibrated extra axes reduced mean repeat error in 16-site panels from six SEEG patients and 24 fMRI adults sci:sha256:7c0a90903c8778e544631e53774eab4fec574bbee872860a83c747f9b5037e6d
Upstream SEEG extraction credited by the inherited reader.
- doi:10.1038/s41583-021-00502-3
- doi:10.1073/pnas.2305853120
- doi:10.1214/aos/1176350174
- usesdoi:10.1371/journal.pbio.3001675
Original human SEEG study.
- usesdoi:10.5281/zenodo.6544488
Version v1.1 source release; analyzed Git bytes are pinned by SHA-256.
- usesdoi:10.1152/jn.00588.2020
Original B2021 fMRI cohort.
- usesdoi:10.1016/j.neuron.2015.11.035
Original NH2015 fMRI cohort.
- usesdoi:10.1371/journal.pbio.3002366
Author release supplies the repeated fMRI arrays used here.
- doi:10.5281/zenodo.8349726
Archived author code associated with the public neural-data download route.
Cited by
1 publicationPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- usesAn order test failed in six SEEG patients and eight fMRI adults; a two-repeat Gaussian product correction was exact in model checks
Time-averaging limit for fixed-scalar interpretations of mean tables.