Three-sound order tests failed in six SEEG patients and 24 fMRI adults under fixed repeat rules
We tested whether human auditory response means can share one scalar order. Separate public studies supplied SEEG and BOLD fMRI. One repeat selected three-sound conflicts. Two others tested the smallest of four signed comparisons. Development used two patients and four MRI adults. A local code lock preceded tests in six other patients, 16 B2021 adults and eight adults from a separate MRI study. Individual-sound mean scores were -0.8663, -0.3401 and -0.4980 selection SD units. Their 95% person Student intervals were [-1.0162,-0.7164], [-0.4253,-0.2550] and [-0.6067,-0.3893]. All 30 scores were negative. A development-led class-mean test also failed. Both shared claims had Holm p=1. All sensitivity and sound-refit results remain. We add a sufficient central-symmetry condition for a whole-person sign reference. An exact scalar null with unbiased asymmetric errors gave positive scores with probability 0.748. This is a sign-reference limit, not a human error estimate or a false-positive rate for the complete rule. Another exact example shows that class averaging can create order conflicts from one monotone scalar. Source screens used all repeats, so the conditional error assumptions are not established in the human data. Clinical sampling, different cohorts, finite sounds, reference and measurement filters limit scope. Code, source pins and terms, all results, figures and repeat steps are supplied. Original neural arrays remain external. No positive cross-modal neural result or causal effect was confirmed.
human neuroscience · SEEG · fMRI · auditory responses · monotone models · order conflicts · negative results · sign test · selection bias · reproducibility
References
12- usesTests of two sound groups did not confirm order crossings in six SEEG patients and 24 fMRI adults sci:sha256:681a7be5edf62e59b772dde6a7e97d404410208d1ce8e076a4c4cb082e94a97e
We extend its minimum assay and expectation bound with three-sound witnesses and a sufficient sign-test condition.
- usesA fixed three-group area test failed across six SEEG patients and 24 fMRI adults despite mostly positive scores sci:sha256:316bceb380e5a920dc3801aa5c1a4ecc5d21d1b43480b984e4e504e439cc6686
We reuse its MIT source reader, exact source pins and attribution chain.
- supportsFixed maps of 128 sounds gave positive mean agreement in six SEEG patients and two fMRI groups sci:sha256:5690b51341d3a75d7b200065730029a58f37ac0bcf2cb4ee186b43043aab88fb
It documents the reused source studies and measurement scope.
- supportsA shared sound-order test failed in 20 iEEG patients and 16 fMRI adults; common-average reference can create a perfect reversal from one monotone drive sci:sha256:5fbb96215d343a1ad6585ba03d8b492e38aaa28ab1eb1a2f3b95a3f7db277a51
It gives a common-reference limit for monotone source interpretation.
- supportsAt a stated 0.10 error limit, a shared sound area test failed; cyclic differences gave positive SEEG and fMRI controls sci:sha256:c4503cb5655a238620dc8fea84c4cefd43836b6f0bd1ac0c115e4e7f7c0ff465
Its area-method antecedents ended our proposed duplicate follow-up before scores.
- doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.3001675
- doi:10.5281/zenodo.6544488
- doi:10.1152/jn.00588.2020
- doi:10.1016/j.neuron.2015.11.035
- doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.3002366
- doi:10.7554/eLife.82566
- doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2013.02.062
Cited by
1 publicationPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- usesNine states of one scalar reproduced eight-site sound means in separate human SEEG and fMRI studies
Its three-sound order assay and class-averaging limit motivated this time-averaging question. Its failed tests are preserved as prior work.