In 15 SEEG subjects, 10–20 principal components preserved working-memory load decoding, but 1–2 components and channel means reduced it
This archived analysis asked whether SEEG working-memory load decoding could use channel-mean band power, a few principal components, or one selected channel instead of the full channel-by-band feature set. It used archived log10 Welch band-power features from 15 subjects performing a verbal Sternberg task, with 464 valid trials for set sizes 4 and 8. A shrinkage LDA decoder was evaluated with stratified 5-fold cross-validation repeated 20 times. The full feature set had mean AUC 0.704, with 14/15 subjects above 0.5. Channel-mean power reduced mean AUC by 0.105 (14/15 subjects lower; Holm-adjusted p = 0.012). The first and second unsupervised principal components reduced mean AUC by 0.155 and 0.122 (Holm-adjusted p = 0.002 and 0.020); 10 and 20 components had mean AUC 0.683 and 0.698, with no significant difference from the full decoder. Selecting one channel in each training fold reduced mean AUC by 0.070 (12/15 lower; Holm-adjusted p = 0.020), and channel selection varied across folds. These results indicate distributed decodable information that is not captured by global mean power or the dominant variance axes, while an unsupervised 10–20 dimensional subspace retained nearly all measured decoding performance. The evidence is limited to one task, one session, 15 clinical SEEG subjects, 20–42 trials per subject, fixed-window log band power, and shrinkage LDA. Small trial counts may favor low-dimensional decoders; this analysis did not test whether more trials increase the gap.
SEEG · working memory · brain-computer interface · dimensionality reduction · principal component analysis · shrinkage LDA · band power · AUC · verbal Sternberg task
References
4- In 15 SEEG patients (OpenNeuro ds004752), a band-power decoder trained only on memory loads 4 and 8 puts load 6 at the midpoint, but its output does not predict response time within a load sci:sha256:e2745563d558339564cbc0b329f8efc977263b7a2e3956a01d641ce57864f0b3
[Legacy relation: reproduces] The full channel x band shrinkage LDA decoder gives mean AUC 0.70 with 14/15 subjects above 0.5, the same as the source result for set size 8 vs 4.
- usesIn 15 SEEG patients (OpenNeuro ds004752), a band-power decoder trained only on memory loads 4 and 8 puts load 6 at the midpoint, but its output does not predict response time within a load sci:sha256:e2745563d558339564cbc0b329f8efc977263b7a2e3956a01d641ce57864f0b3
Uses the archived ds004752 log band-power feature files (data/feat/sub-XX.npz), trial flags, and raw-file provenance.
- usesIn session 1 of 15 patients, IEDs did not decode memory load; masking raised SEEG AUC from 0.70 to 0.72 sci:sha256:632c406c34e1530eea3bb23516da5054eb6c64dbaa63783d6d4628a34fe21bbb
The feature extraction (bipolar montage, notch filter, Welch band power in the 3-6 s window) that produced the features.
- doi:10.7554/eLife.78677
Cited by
2 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- supportsIn 8 SEEG subjects, PCA-16 reduced mean AUC by 0.013, but non-inferiority to full features was not shown
Same pattern in a motor task: 1-2 unsupervised PCs lose AUC, about 16 or more PCs come near the full set.
- usesArchived SEEG pipelines agree on patient decodability rankings, but shared trial noise explains about 38% of patient variance
Per-patient load 8 vs 4 AUC table (column full) is one pipeline in the cross-pipeline matrix.