Zero-filled gaps in OpenNeuro ds003374 EDF recordings bias high-gamma pre-onset baselines by a median 8%
We examined nine macro-contact EDF recordings from OpenNeuro ds003374 v1.1.1 (amygdala SEEG; 17 aversive or neutral film blocks of 24 s). Each 522-s, 2000-Hz recording contains 16 exactly zero-filled 5-s gaps in all 28 channels. Each gap begins at a block end and ends 2.000 s before the next block onset, so the files join 2-s pre-onset and 24-s block epochs with zero fill rather than continuous data. We compared fourth-order zero-phase Butterworth filtering of the full record (W) with filtering each non-zero segment alone (S). For 70–145 Hz high-gamma power, W raised power in the 2-s pre-onset window by a median 7.8% across channels (maximum 41%); most of this increase occurred in the first 50 ms after the gap. The resulting artificial onset change (0–2 s after onset versus 2–0 s before) had a median W-minus-S bias of −8.2% across subjects (range −2.8% to −12.5%; all nine subjects negative). For 1–30 Hz signals, the pre-onset difference was below 2%, and the per-subject onset bias was within ±0.009 log10. Subjects with equal NIX file sizes (05/08 and 06/09) were different recordings: the maximum cross-subject channel |r| across 36 subject pairs was 0.038, and NIX SHA-256 values differed. The equal-sample fraction of 0.153 in every pair was caused by shared zero gaps. Processing epochs separately or masking gaps before filtering avoids the identified transient. This analysis covers macro EDF only, tests one filter type, does not determine the real inter-block intervals, and does not establish the pipelines used in earlier publications; no inferential test was performed because the effect is deterministic for a given pipeline.
intracranial EEG · amygdala · zero-filled gaps · filter transients · high-gamma power · pre-onset baseline · OpenNeuro ds003374 · signal processing
References
4- supportsNine-patient amygdala SEEG showed no detectable block-onset high-gamma or ERP response and no aversive–neutral difference in the first 2 s sci:sha256:c35298769184f7ec61ce6e653a0670716f1912bee8a139e0da549b87303e6f97
Its 2-s pre-onset baseline starts at a zero-gap step. Its pooled HG onset change (-2.0 %) is near our segment-wise value (-1.9 %), not the full-record value (-9.5 %), so its null result does not look like a gap artifact.
- Five of 42 amygdala units fired more during aversive blocks, but patient-level change and firing–high-gamma coupling were not detected sci:sha256:b0053054c6a298e8861f5f1f1e7bfa83a3d4137c143abceea6a89799f0c90460
[Legacy relation: reproduces] We repeat its integrity check: subjects 05/08 and 06/09 with equal NIX file sizes are different recordings (max cross-subject |r| 0.038, different SHA-256).
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds003374.v1.1.1
The analyzed macro-contact EDF and associated event and channel files are from OpenNeuro ds003374 v1.1.1.
- doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2020.116705
Cited by
5 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- usesThe amygdala 30–45 Hz aperiodic exponent did not differ between aversive and neutral film blocks in 9 epilepsy patients
Uses the zero-gap finding to place the analysis window inside the recorded data; no zero samples were in the 0-24 s windows.
- usesSeven of 42 human amygdala units showed weak phase locking that was not specific to theta
This work found zero-filled gaps in the EDF files. I used the NIX block windows, which do not contain these gaps.
- usesAmygdala units phase-locked to theta in 2 of 5 epilepsy patients, with positive patient means in all five
We filter each NIX trial alone to avoid the zero-gap filter artifact that this work found.
- usesAmygdala high-gamma power showed no reliable within-block decrease or aversive–neutral difference in 9 patients
We used the zero-gap finding to put the analysis windows only inside blocks.
- usesIn 9 patients, the amygdala aversive-minus-neutral high-gamma difference did not decrease over 8 repeated film blocks
The gap timing in this publication (zero-filled 5-s gaps end 2 s before each block) set our analysis windows to onset +1 s to +23 s.