Fixed tests did not confirm more than one category response direction in 14 SEEG patients and five fMRI adults
We tested if object categories produce more than one stable spatial response direction after a constant animal/person-versus-other pattern is removed. Separate public studies supplied SEEG high-gamma amplitude and BOLD fMRI. Two pictures per category set site scales. Different pictures estimated two test halves. Disjoint within-class category contrasts gave one signed area score per person. Development used three patients. A revised plan and code lock preceded tests in 14 other eligible patients and all five MRI adults. Mean areas were -0.00008564 and 0.00015700. Their 95% person Student limits were [-0.00023919,0.00006790] and [-0.00008392,0.00039791]. The shared positive-mean and sign-flip rule failed, p=0.87516. Controls with eight sites and separate MRI runs were also uncertain. Negative and discordant results remain. An exact model exposed an interpretation limit. Independent picture halves with zero mean gave positive area in all four sign outcomes when categories shared errors. Four independent groups removed that model bias. The initial four-group human design failed contact coverage in development. Independent source calculations matched all 19 included scores within 4.21e-19. A full source repeat matched recorded result bytes. The contribution is a negative visual benchmark, checked area tools and an exact error model. Separate cohorts and pictures, source order, missingness, sparse clinical sites, five MRI people and unequal filters limit scope. No positive cross-modal neural effect, common source count or cause was established. Code, source versions and terms, all scalar results, figures and repeat steps are supplied. Original neural arrays remain external.
human neuroscience · SEEG · fMRI · visual categories · response rank · signal moments · independent errors · negative result
References
12- usesA fixed test did not confirm taxonomic geometry beyond animacy and visual controls in 14 SEEG patients and five fMRI adults sci:sha256:5a567459d8b1c2326517239ed17a59053cffae7954e83f22468ef24abd0042a8
We reuse category mappings and adapted source-reader lineage, with MIT attribution.
- usesA fixed pleasantness geometry test did not confirm a shared relation in 14 SEEG patients and five fMRI adults sci:sha256:9890041ed80a7e2d6b10982df7b9e72d74dc98479c76b452fa2f3a8cd11d346b
We adapt the public input pins, HDF5 source reader and category-order logic. We recompute all new neural scores from the original sources.
- usesSound response areas were positive after class mean removal in selected data from six SEEG patients and two fMRI cohorts sci:sha256:b9fb134f2edb5d53be25b14de20f246740c623872c4893148a7ae7deb2ee664c
Related auditory area methods and interpretation limits inform this distinct visual benchmark. Its human scores and arrays are not reused as new evidence.
- usesdoi:10.1371/journal.pbio.3003614
Public SEEG source, OSF muq48. Two source files are pinned at version 1; original neural arrays remain external.
- usesdoi:10.1038/ncomms15037
Human Generic Object Decoding study supplies the separate MRI cohort and experimental design.
- usesdoi:10.1038/sdata.2019.12
Documents the compact MRI responses and source metadata.
- usesdoi:10.5281/zenodo.1742390
Fixed compact MRI data record. All five subject files have exact source hashes.
- usesdoi:10.6084/m9.figshare.7387130.v8
Version 8 author mirror supplies identical MRI subject files. Model features in this record are not used.
- doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2013.02.062
- doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2018.06.015
- doi:10.48550/arXiv.2509.26560
- doi:10.7554/eLife.82566
Cited by
2 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- usesA fixed auditory response fit did not pass a shared repeat error test in six SEEG patients and 16 fMRI adults
Builds on its stated error-dependence and neural-rank interpretation limits; no source human outcome is reused as evidence.
- usesFixed nonvoice sound contrasts gave positive mean repeat areas in six SEEG patients and sixteen fMRI adults
We adapt its disjoint-contrast estimator and reproduce its sound-error independence limit.