For 54 sounds, donor panel gains were uncertain in six SEEG patients and positive in 24 fMRI adults
We tested whether neural donor responses can select 16 sounds that improve response-contrast forecasts for 54 other sounds. Public SEEG high-gamma activity and BOLD fMRI came from separate human studies. Development used two patients and four adults. A local code lock preceded tests in six other patients and 16 other adults. Reference panels had the same broad-class counts. Mean gains were 2.694% and 3.316% of test contrast energy. Their 95% person t intervals were [-0.308,5.697]% and [2.861,3.771]%. Five of six patients and all 16 adults improved. The fixed shared mean-and-sign rule failed, p=0.109375. The same BOLD donor model and panels gave mean gain 3.259% in eight adults from another study, interval [1.896,4.623]%, with all positive. A planned donor-label shuffle still gave positive mean panel gains in all three cohorts. Every shuffled model had negative skill against zero contrast prediction. A later exact zero-mean model gave positive gain through lower fitted-noise amplification, without sound signal or constant-response gains. Short-baseline subtraction removed the electrical benefit. A first order-term check was unstable; a later projection retained SEEG uncertainty. These checks do not repair the primary failure. Independent calculations checked all 30 reserved people within 4e-16. The package gives code, source pins and terms, all outcomes, fitted maps, figures, plans and repeat steps. Source selection, cohort differences, measurement filters, fixed sounds and small electrical sample limit scope. No common neural cause or positive primary cross-modal benefit is established.
SEEG · fMRI · auditory cortex · experimental design · donor responses · sound selection · response contrasts · negative result · measurement noise · reproducible research
References
14- usesA fixed sound panel test did not confirm shared gains in 20 iEEG patients and 16 fMRI adults sci:sha256:c90376886d6419357431a8357251ec70bda279f1cbafd1079c06ded4813c5d2a
We build on its panel benchmark and overall-response interpretation limit. We use neural donor features and response contrasts.
- usesAdded guide patterns reduced test sound response error in SEEG and two fMRI cohorts with source processing sci:sha256:093bb5db0f1ab9c679b9961c2192c109be77a94fc41333105aeed3164edd3a54
We reuse its verified public-source preparation code and exact source pins.
- usesFor 165 fixed sounds, four-component models reduced repeat error in six SEEG patients and 24 fMRI adults sci:sha256:1ffb0217c831625cbe8fc949585c14c1f283f7e9f1b2113e69122af88fa9a59b
Upstream preparation-code attribution retained through SCI 72b300b9.
- usesSpeech and song axes gave positive mean repeat scores for nine voice clips in SEEG and two fMRI cohorts sci:sha256:6720e49a50bda02902607508181e2616c7f5e48b21bceee56a2d3fcdc618bdae
Original preparation-code attribution retained through the source chain.
- doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.3001675
- doi:10.5281/zenodo.6544488
- doi:10.1152/jn.00588.2020
- doi:10.1016/j.neuron.2015.11.035
- doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.3002366
- doi:10.5281/zenodo.8349726
- doi:10.1613/jair.295
- doi:10.1137/15M1017119
- doi:10.1371/journal.pcbi.1002280
- doi:10.1016/j.cub.2022.01.069
Cited by
5 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- usesA fixed test with two donor maps did not confirm a shared sound prediction gain in six SEEG patients and 24 fMRI adults
Prior donor-based sound panel test; our forecast endpoint and fixed donor weighting differ.
- usesFour low-repeatability guides failed a shared prediction test in six SEEG patients and 16 fMRI adults
Verified source preparation and fetch code, version pins, and the warning that gain alone does not establish useful prediction.
- usesA fixed 32-sound selection rule failed its shared accuracy test in 21 iEEG patients and 16 fMRI adults
Prior warning that a panel gain can coexist with negative prediction skill.
- usesMean sound class scores from repeat spread were above chance in six SEEG patients and 16 fMRI adults; a fixed shared test failed
We reuse its pinned source preparation and fetch code with attribution.
- usesFor fixed sounds, panels learned from other people lowered mean prediction error in 20 iEEG patients and 16 fMRI adults
Prior neural donor panel benchmark and its negative shared result limit novelty and interpretation.