Within-patient SEEG sites under 10 mm apart showed excess percept-quality agreement, but effects varied across patients
We tested whether nearby stereo-electroencephalography (SEEG) stimulation sites in the same patient and hemisphere evoked visual percepts with more similar qualities. We used percept labels and native-space contact coordinates from OpenNeuro ds005169 v1.0.0 (43–50 Hz direct cortical stimulation; 20 patients). Each site was the midpoint of its two stimulated contacts. For 420 pairs among 104 sites, agreement was the fraction of three binary quality labels (dynamic, intermittent hallucination, color) that matched. A 10,000-permutation null shuffled label vectors within patient and hemisphere. Quality agreement decreased with distance (Spearman rho = -0.187, one-sided permutation p = 0.027). Pairs 0–10 mm apart agreed more than the null (0.762 vs. 0.694; p = 0.023); pairs at 10–20, 20–40, and >40 mm were not above the null. Results remained after adjustment for current difference (p = 0.028) and session gap (p = 0.042), and when seven missing contact coordinates were imputed along their shafts (rho = -0.223, p = 0.011). Same-shaft pairs at 20 mm or less had 0.147 greater agreement than other pairs (p = 0.042). Location-label agreement had a stronger distance association (rho = -0.233, p = 0.0002), with excess agreement in the 0–10 and 10–20 mm bins. No individual quality label was significant after Holm correction, and only six of ten patient-hemisphere groups with at least four sites had negative rho (sign test p = 0.25); the pooled effect was not consistent across patients. Each session contained one stimulation, so the planned same-session control was replaced by adjustment for session-index gap. The small sample, binary patient reports, native-space coordinates, possible regional confounding, and pooled result driven by patients with many sites limit interpretation. The result suggests that contacts more than approximately 10 mm apart may evoke independent percept qualities, but does not establish a consistent effect in each patient.
stereo-electroencephalography · SEEG · direct cortical stimulation · visual percepts · percept quality · site distance · permutation test · visual prosthesis
References
3- usesAll 53 lateralized percepts were contralateral to stimulated hemispheres in a 20-patient SEEG dataset sci:sha256:09ee519118ab832c8916523625e47a21681a7f9cb0e64b0dbc15a0766bc51864
Percept events and electrode tables of ds005169 v1.0.0 copied without change from this package.
- usesReported current at visual percepts increased with lateral SEEG position in 20 patients sci:sha256:e1d7ad652695e4d65bc61f3208ac0f21929a87dcebc3d5c444c4df8a1fef1210
Shaft-line imputation of missing contact coordinates, used here only in a sensitivity analysis.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds005169.v1.0.0
The analysis used the v1.0.0 percept-event labels and native-space electrode coordinates for the reported SEEG stimulation sites.
Cited by
4 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- usesSEEG stimulation position showed no detected within-patient difference by visual percept label in 9-patient tests
Uses the same colour and dynamic percept labels; this work tests site position, not pairwise quality similarity.
- usesSEEG site position did not predict color or dynamic visual percepts within patients
Source of the archived ds005169 events and electrodes files; same site and imputation rule.
- supportsNear SEEG Stimulation Sites Were Less Separable in Two Patients, but Distance Predicted Accuracy in Only One
9a049030 found similar percepts for stimulation sites less than 10 mm apart (ds005169). In ds004457 we find, with a different measure (single-trial response separability, not percepts), that site pairs less than 10 mm apart are separable less often (36-82%) than pairs 20-40 mm apart (90-97%) in 2 patients. The support is indirect because the measures differ.
- usesIn 20 SEEG patients, whole-field visual percepts were not linked to higher reported stimulation current (OpenNeuro ds005169; ratio 0.94, 95% CI 0.76–1.13)
Events and electrode TSV files and the contact-coordinate code were copied from this package.